Search and compare the best products.

10 Best Pencil Eyeliners of 2021

No. 1
Rimmel London Soft Kohl Smudge-proof Eyeliner Pencil, Jet Black, 1.2 gRecommended by Tickrater
  • Intense colour, easy application
  • Soft and blendable formula for an easy Smokey look
  • Smudge-proof long wear formula up to 12 hours wear
  • Dermatologist and ophthalmologist tested
No. 2
COLLECTION Kohl Number 1 Eyeliner, Bl
1,461 Reviews
COLLECTION Kohl Number 1 Eyeliner, BlackRecommended by Tickrater
  • COLLECTION Supersoft Kohl Eyeliner Pencil with Intense Colour, Black.
  • Super soft blendable kohl pencil with intense colour pay off.
  • Our Supersoft Kohl Everyliner Pencils contain 50% moisturising ingredients.
  • Waterproof formula for fabulous flicks rain or shine.
  • Available in Black and Brown.
SaleNo. 3
Rimmel Exaggerate Waterproof Eye, Definer NoirRecommended by Tickrater
  • Soft creamy texture in a retractable pencil with built-in smudger for subtle blending and sharpener for high precision line
  • Waterproof formula for up to 10 hours long-lasting wear
  • Choose your shade from creamy matte to high metallic; all highly pigmented in intense and vivid hue
  • Use rimmel exaggerate waterproof eye definer to turn heads with sexy and statement eyes
  • Rimmel's innovative formula gives you colour that hits you between the eyes
SaleNo. 4
Rimmel London Scandaleyes Waterproof Eyeliner, Black, 1.3 gRecommended by Tickrater
  • Professional precision with soft pencil and waterproof formula
  • Ultimate long-lasting resistance: withstands tears, sweat, humidity, rubbing
  • Ultra smooth and creamy formula; available in a range of vivid colours
  • Gliders on easily, smudge-proof and long wear effect
  • Safe for sensitive eyes
SaleNo. 5
Maybelline Color Show Crayon Khol Eyeliner Pencil Number 100, Ultra BlackRecommended by Tickrater
  • The super creamy pencil will effortlessly glide's across your eye lid for the perfect shape
  • Discover Ultra black
  • deep and creamy jet
  • made from rich pigments for incredible definition
  • Enjoy the smudge proof formula for long-lasting wear.
No. 6
Saffron - Soft Kajal Kohl Eyeliner Pencil (117 Azure)
48 Reviews
Saffron - Soft Kajal Kohl Eyeliner Pencil (117 Azure)Recommended by Tickrater
  • Saffron Kohl pencil with smooth texture glides on easily for precise lines or Smokey looks. Rich in pigments for amazing eye intensity.
  • Available in 3 Colours: Grey, Forest Green, Azure
  • 1.2g net
SaleNo. 7
Max Factor Kohl Pencil Eyeliner, 20 Black, Easy to Blend Formula, Perfect...Recommended by Tickrater
  • Ultra soft and gentle on eyes; easy to apply in one stroke
  • Soft pencil is firm enough to create an eye-defining shape
  • Smudge for shadowing effect on lids or under bottom lashes
  • The ideal for seductive smokey eyes
  • Easy to apply
SaleNo. 9
12pcs Highlighter Eyeliner Pen Eyeshadow Pencil White Eyeliner Pencil...Recommended by Tickrater
  • It has long wearing not fade, waterproof, highlight the eye, make the eye full of temptation.
  • You can use it as a eyeliner, eye shadow pen, highlighter, open the corner of the eye makeup, lip gloss, etc.
  • Available in a wide shade range to mix, match, line and layer.
  • The white eyeliner pencil goes on smooth. Fine tipped for precise, texture, strong stretch performance, can draw a detailed eyeliner, not blooming.
  • The Water proof white Eyeliner pen is specially formulated to last all day.
SaleNo. 10
Rimmel Soft Kohl Kajal Professional Eyeliner Pencil, Denim Blue, 1.2 gramsRecommended by Tickrater
  • Soft, smudgeable colour with staying power
  • Long wear finish — up to 12 hours
  • Dense colour blends easily into eyelid for a soft, smudged look
  • Soft, smooth texture goes on easily
  • Won't tug or drag on delicate skin

Last update on 2021-05-08 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Best Pencil Eyeliners Buying Guide

Are you shopping for great Pencil Eyeliners? Are you looking for a bargain, the best value, or the top-of-the-range model? Are you finding research to be stressful?
We know the feeling, which is exactly why we’ve done all the research for you. We’ve looked at all the options when it comes to Pencil Eyeliners, and we’ve come up with what we think are the greatest Pencil Eyeliners on the market today. Also, we’ve covered all the questions you might have, so you know you’re getting a great deal.

When it comes to buying the best, we can anticipate many of the questions you might have, and we know exactly what features you’re looking for when it comes to Pencil Eyeliners. To meet your requirements, we think you might need to know the answers to the following questions:

  • Should I buy Pencil Eyeliners?
  • What will Pencil Eyeliners do for me?
  • What should I look for when shopping for quality Pencil Eyeliners?
  • What’s the difference between good Pencil Eyeliners and the best ones?
  • Which models or manufacturers are currently leading the market?
  • Where should I go if I want to learn more about Pencil Eyeliners?

While the above questions are far from comprehensive, and you probably have far more concerning Pencil Eyeliners. This buying guide and recommendations should help arm you with the knowledge you need to get a great deal. If you have any other additional questions please feel free to reach out to us and we’ll get back to you as soon as we can.

If you’d like to do your research elsewhere, then there are near endless buying guides for Pencil Eyeliners available online, through specialist reviewers, subject matter experts, as well as word of mouth reviews. Getting a great deal and one of the best performing Pencil Eyeliners is not difficult, look at our guide and review our recommendations.

Our Pencil Eyeliners buying guide is 100 percent unbiased and based on real experiences, market data, user feedback, and authenticity. Our suite of tools includes machine learning AI, augmented big data analytics, as well as good old-fashioned research, testing, and understanding.

Combined together this allows us to put together a comprehensive top 10 best available Pencil Eyeliners.

Our processes and procedures that allow us to make buying recommendations are based on a scientific process that includes but is not limited to the following:

1. Brand Recognition and Value: Every manufacturer and brand of Pencil Eyeliners has its own distinct set of values. Most offer something unique, but that doesn’t necessarily equate to good. We look at these factors when making our guides and recommendations.
2. Selling Points: When stripped back to be basics, what matters when it comes to Pencil Eyeliners?
3. What’s included: Are they packed with every feature and made to meet our stringent criteria?
4. Value for money: Are you getting a great deal when you buy Pencil Eyeliners?
5. Customer Satisfaction: Are customers consistently rating the product well above average?
6. Long-term value: Is the buying experience short-lived? Have we found that some users are having a bad experience? What does that tell us about Pencil Eyeliners?
7. Field Tested Quality: When we tested the Pencil Eyeliners in real-world scenarios, did it live up to expectations? Was it lacking in a particular area or was there an area in which it exceeded?
8. Reliability: If the Pencil Eyeliners are well made with a professional finish, then it can be an indication of a product that is expected to last longer than most.

We know that new Pencil Eyeliners might be released any day, which is why we are constantly updating our top 10 list to ensure we have the latest information. Check back regularly to find updates, new reviews, and changes made to our list.

If you find that any of our information is incorrect, biased, wrong, or no longer accurate, then please do reach out to us and let us know. You can always reach out to us via our contact form. If you would like more information on our website’s purpose, then take a look at our vision statement here.

Tick Rater
Login/Register access is temporary disabled